Geranium bronze (Cacyreus marshalli), a species in the family Lycaenidae.
Photo: M.violante 12:38, 28 June 2006 (UTC) · Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA
Contents
  1. Identification
  2. Range and habitat
  3. Life cycle and host plants
  4. Behaviour and flight period
  5. Conservation
  6. Similar species

The geranium bronze, Cacyreus marshalli, is a small brown Lycaenidae butterfly native to southern Africa whose caterpillars bore into the stems and flower buds of geraniums and pelargoniums, rather than simply grazing on leaves, and has become a pest to cultivated Pelargonium and Geranium species. The species is native to South Africa, including KwaZulu-Natal and the Cape provinces. Accounts differ on when it reached Europe: one source dates the first introduction to 1978, UK Butterflies dates the first Balearic Islands colony to about 19872, and Naturalis dates the first European sighting to 19903. It reached Rome by 1996, and a 2017 EPPO listing1 recorded established colonies across Belgium, Germany, the Netherlands, Italy, France, Greece, Malta, Spain, Portugal, southern Switzerland, Slovenia and Croatia.

Identification

This is a small butterfly: males span 15 to 23 mm and females 18 to 23 mm. The upperside of the wings is brown with a bronze sheen and a white border outlining the margin1, while the underside is grey-brown with darker bands interlaced with white, forming an intricate pattern, and the hindwing carries an eyespot that helps divert predators from attacking. The hindwings also end in short tail-like projections. The observer who recorded the species’ first British sighting first took it for a Brown argus behaving strangely, then noticed the tails and guessed Lang’s short-tailed blue, until another observer described a photograph of the geranium bronze and the family confirmed the identification themselves. Males and females look similar overall, though one early British record described a specimen as smaller, darker and more distinctly marked2, which may point to a male.

Range and habitat

Beyond its native South African range, the species was recorded as a vagrant sighting in Brussels in 1991 and the Netherlands in 1999, and today it occurs across much of southern and eastern Europe, including the Balearic Islands, Spain, France and Italy. It lives wherever its host plants are grown, favouring urban parks, gardens, towns and villages with geranium and pelargonium plants, both ornamental and wild Geraniaceae. This tie to a widely planted garden flower, more than to any particular terrain, is what has let it spread, likely through accidental transportation of infested plants1 between countries; in cooler regions it lacks a diapause stage and can only establish itself temporarily3, so each cold winter can wipe out a northern colony.

Life cycle and host plants

Caterpillars feed on Pelargonium and Geranium species, including cultivated garden geraniums. One early British rearing found that most young larvae burrowed into the flower buds, while a few mined the leaves first before moving to the underside, and the stem typically turns black where it has been invaded. The eggs are tiny, about 0.5 mm across and 0.3 mm high, changing from pale green to white and then to brown or yellow before hatching. Through four instars the caterpillar grows from about 1 mm to around 13 mm, and most caterpillars are yellow or green, sometimes with pink markings. In South Africa the full life cycle from egg to adult takes about 46 days2. The species is multivoltine, producing two or more broods per year, and it has been suggested to overwinter as either a caterpillar or a pupa1, though further data is needed to confirm this.

Behaviour and flight period

Where winters are mild, adults fly for most of the year; in South Africa the flight period typically runs from August to May. Because the larvae feed hidden inside stems and buds, not on exposed leaf surfaces, contact pesticides generally fail against them; one study found the bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis may help control it, alongside insecticides such as diflubenzuron, flufenoxuron, hexaflumuron, lambda-cyhalothrin, alphamethrin and benfuracarb. As of a 2017 EPPO listing, the butterfly is classed as an A2 quarantine pest for Europe1 and an A1 pest for Turkey, a reflection of the real economic damage it does to the ornamental geranium trade.

Conservation

The species is listed Least Concern, on the IUCN Red List’s 2022 assessment4. Far from being at risk, the species is instead treated as an agricultural pest: efforts are made to contain its spread1, not to conserve a vulnerable population.

Similar species

  • Brown argus (Aricia agestis): in the British record that first confused the two, the tails on the hind wings2 gave the geranium bronze away.
  • Lang’s short-tailed blue (Leptotes pirithous): also tailed, but larger, spanning 21-30 mm against the geranium bronze’s 15-23 mm5 — similar enough that the same British record first mistook a geranium bronze for this species, until another observer described a photograph of the geranium bronze2 and the family confirmed it themselves.