Contents
Berger’s clouded yellow, Colias alfacariensis, is a pale yellow butterfly of the family Pieridae, ranging across South and Central Europe to temperate China, also taking in Asia Minor, the Caucasus, Siberia and Central Asia. Its northern edge reaches 54°N in Poland, and occasional vagrants reach further northwest, into southern England, the North German plain and Denmark1. It has been recorded from sea level up to 2,100 metres2.
It is so close in looks to the pale clouded yellow that the two cannot be told apart by morphology or by a genitalia examination, only by rearing from the caterpillar. One account puts its recognition as a distinct species in 1905, when Heinrich Ribbe first separated it; UK Butterflies gives the same 1905 description but dates its recognition as a species distinct from the pale clouded yellow to 1945, described by L.A. Berger3, after whom the species is named. Several regional populations have since been named as subspecies, among them vihorlatensis in the Carpathians and saissanica in Kazakhstan, and the species has also travelled under other names later synonymised, including Colias sareptensis and Colias australis1.
Identification
The male has a yellow ground colour with a dusted dark marginal band and a red-bordered orange hindwing spot; on the underside, that spot stays bright and clearly outlined in red. The female is paler, with a greenish-white ground colour above and an orange hindwing spot that, unlike the male’s, lacks a red border1. Wingspan runs to about 50–60 mm3.
Adults of the two species are, UK Butterflies notes, a case where even experienced lepidopterists are unable to tell them apart, and only rearing from the caterpillar settles the question. UK Butterflies describes the reared larva as carrying a yellow stripe along each side of the body3; another account instead gives Berger’s clouded yellow’s own caterpillar four yellow lines with black dots1, against only two thin side lines on the look-alike’s. The two accounts do not agree on the pattern of Berger’s clouded yellow’s own caterpillar, so rearing and comparing the caterpillars remains the only sure way to separate the species.
Range and habitat
The species favours dry limestone grassland and steppe, chiefly on south-facing slopes2 in the cooler, northern parts of its range, and avoids cool, rainy regions1 more generally. In Britain, where it turns up only as a vagrant, it has been found on coastal cliffs and open downland, the same ground favoured by the clouded yellow there. It would appear that none of its life stages can survive the British winter, though individuals seen near Folkestone in May 1948 were thought to have survived a mild one3.
Life cycle and host plants
Caterpillars feed mainly on horseshoe vetch, with crown vetch taken as a secondary food plant on the continent. Eggs are laid singly on these host plants’ leaves and hatch in 7 to 10 days. Being more cold-sensitive than the pale clouded yellow, it grows more slowly, with diapauses in bad weather. It then overwinters on the host plant or in leaf litter, and spins itself to the host plant before forming a light-green girdle pupa2, a stage that lasts from just over a week to nearly three weeks3.
Behaviour and flight period
Both sources agree on two or three generations a year: one count gives two generations, in May-June and August-September, or three from May to October, the other, Dagvlinders van Europa, two to three generations, from April to October2; adults feed at flowers1 across the warm, dry grassland and scrub they favour. As a vagrant to Britain it most often appears in August or early September, occasionally as early as May or June, with the latest-ever sighting on 27 October 1945 near Glynde, East Sussex. It has been one of the rarer migrants recorded there: relatively good numbers were seen each year from 1947 to 1949, but such numbers have not been matched since, and it has gone unrecorded in some years altogether; most historic British specimens came from the south coast of England, especially Kent, the earliest in 1875 at Folkestone3.
Similar species
- Pale clouded yellow (Colias hyale): so similar that adults cannot be told apart by morphology or by a genitalia examination1, only the reared caterpillars. The two also part company on habitat: Berger’s clouded yellow is found almost only on limestone grassland with horseshoe vetch, while the pale clouded yellow favours clover and lucerne fields2 and disperses more widely.
- Clouded yellow (Colias croceus): shares the same cliff-and-downland ground in Britain, and UK Butterflies judges Berger’s clouded yellow is probably overlooked given its similarity3 to the much commoner clouded yellow, especially the pale helice form of the clouded yellow’s female.
_Colias_alfacariensis_-_Novy_Jicin__Moravie_Tch%C3%A9quie_-_female_Zgm502.webp)
_Colias_croceus_-_Durfort_Tarn_France_-_male_ZvAIWE.webp)


_Colias_hyale_-_Novy_Jicin_Moravie_Czech_Republic_-_male_Z1RdClK.webp)

_Aporia_crataegi-_Foret_de_Soreze_Tarn_France_-_male_25HPdB.webp)

_Gonepteryx_rhamni_-_Pr%C3%A9serville_France_-_male_KFu9N.webp)