Clouded yellow (Colias croceus), a species in the family Pieridae.
Photo: Didier Descouens · Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA
Contents
  1. Identification
  2. Range and habitat
  3. Life cycle and host plants
  4. Behaviour and flight period
  5. Similar species

The clouded yellow, Colias croceus, is a fast-flying1 orange-yellow butterfly of the family Pieridae that breeds continuously through the year in southern Europe and North Africa, where its breeding range runs to the Middle East2; its wider range reaches north to central Siberia and barely south into India, and it is also a strongly migratory species, reaching northern Europe in immigration years, including the British Isles.

Identification

The butterfly almost always settles with its wings closed, so the pattern most often seen is the underside: lighter than the upperside and tinged greenish on the forewing, with the same dark spot as on the upperside but often pale-centred, a white spot on the hindwing (often with a smaller dot above it) and, sometimes, black dots along the outer margins. In flight, the upperside shows its golden to orange-yellow ground colour with a broad black margin on all four wings and a black spot near the centre of the forewing. Sources disagree on the wingspan: 45–54 mm2 by one count, or, per UK Butterflies, 52–58 mm in males and 54–62 mm in females3.

The sexes differ on the upperside: females carry yellow spots set into the black border, which males lack. Most females are coloured like the male, but about 5% are a pale cream rather than golden-yellow, a form called helice that is not clearly distinct, and only loosely tied to humidity during development, since intermediates exist; UK Butterflies records both the yellow and the helice form across the British Isles3. Pale helice females can be mistaken for Colias hyale or Colias alfacariensis; by one account C. croceus tends to keep more black on the hindwing than either2, and UK Butterflies gives the clouded yellow’s lemon-yellow underside against both look-alikes’ much paler one4 as a further mark (see Similar species).

Range and habitat

Outside its migrations the clouded yellow favours open ground such as downland, coastal cliffs and flowery fields2 carrying its caterpillars’ food plants, from sea level up to about 1,600 m. The Naturalis Biodiversity Center’s Butterflies of Europe describes it more broadly as a habitat generalist, found on fields of clover or lucerne, or other flower-rich vegetation1. The British Isles population is primarily made up of immigrants from southern Europe and northern Africa3; many of the arrivals stay near the coast, where they feed, mate and lay eggs, so sightings cluster there and on other open flowery ground, with their offspring swelling numbers through the rest of the season.

Life cycle and host plants

Caterpillars feed on legumes, including clovers, alfalfa and bird’s-foot trefoil (Trifolium, Medicago sativa, Lotus corniculatus) and vetches (Vicia). Females lay their eggs singly, and the caterpillar pupates in a silken girdle on the food plant itself, per the Naturalis Biodiversity Center. Overwintering depends on the climate: in the south, where it can survive the cold, the species hibernates as a chrysalis, per the Naturalis Biodiversity Center, while further north UK Butterflies records larvae overwintering at some coastal sites, with lower success3. Breeding runs fast where the climate allows: one count, citing UK Butterflies, gives as many as three generations a year in Britain2, while the Naturalis Biodiversity Center gives four to six broods a year across the species’ wider range1.

Behaviour and flight period

Across its resident range the clouded yellow is on the wing from March to October2. In the British Isles the pattern is set by immigration: butterflies mainly arrive from late May or June, with numbers peaking in July and August, as successive waves cross the Channel and breed locally for the rest of the season. The Naturalis Biodiversity Center calls it a very fast flyer1; even on the wing it is often mistaken for one of the commoner whites, but UK Butterflies notes that despite this, the orange-yellow colour is quite distinctive and unlike any other species3 while it is airborne; once it settles with its wings closed, it is the lemon-coloured underside4 that gives it away.

Similar species

  • Pale clouded yellow (Colias hyale): found across most of Europe5, overlapping the clouded yellow’s range, and one of the species a pale helice-form female clouded yellow can be confused with; by one account C. croceus tends to keep more black on the hindwing2 than either look-alike, and UK Butterflies gives its lemon-yellow underside against both look-alikes’ much paler one4 as a further mark.
  • Berger’s clouded yellow (Colias alfacariensis): another look-alike raised by the same pale-form confusion; as with the pale clouded yellow, C. croceus is told apart by more black on the hindwing2 and a lemon-yellow underside against Berger’s much paler one4.
  • Brimstone (Gonepteryx rhamni): a paler, lemon-yellow butterfly; the clouded yellow’s orange-yellow is much brighter than the lemon-yellow male brimstone, which also lacks black markings2.