Pale clouded yellow (Colias hyale), a species in the family Pieridae.
Photo: Didier Descouens · Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA
Contents
  1. Identification
  2. Range and habitat
  3. Life cycle and host plants
  4. Behaviour and flight period
  5. Similar species

The pale clouded yellow, Colias hyale, is a lemon-yellow butterfly of the family Pieridae, found across most of Europe and large parts of the Palearctic region. Resident across most of Central Europe, it is migratory in the northern part of its range2, reaching the British Isles only as an extremely rare immigrant, recorded mainly in southern England and the Channel Islands, with strays as far north as Scotland and the Inner Hebrides in 1947. Sources disagree on Ireland: UK Butterflies also lists the south of Ireland among the species’ regular areas3, while another account records only a single confirmed Irish sighting, in 1868. It is also a rare migrant in Scandinavia1.

Identification

Males measure 52 to 56 mm across the wings and females 52 to 62 mm3. The male’s upperside is light lemon yellow with black margins on both wings, carrying a large black spot on the forewing and an orange-yellow double spot at the hindwing centre. The underside is bright yellow with red-brown spots and a mother-of-pearl double spot on the hindwing. The female differs sharply: her upperside and the base of her forewing underside are white rather than yellow, with a slight yellowish cast overall. The caterpillar is bluish green or grass green with a velvety texture, its back crossed by blackish dots and yellow lines; the chrysalis is green with yellow stripes along the sides. The head and antennae are red-brown1, as are the fringes along both wing edges.

Range and habitat

Across its range the species favours flower meadows up to 2,000 m above sea level1, together with fallow land, waste ground and dry calcareous or siliceous grassland, open landscapes with few trees or bushes2. In Britain, sightings cluster on coastal cliffs, open downland and fields growing lucerne or clover, the caterpillars’ food plants. The scale of those sightings has fallen a long way from its peak: 8,500 records between 1826 and 1950, more than 2,000 of them in 1900 alone, and strong annual numbers from 1945 to 1949 — a run of good years that has not been matched since, leaving the pale clouded yellow one of Britain’s rarest migrants3.

Life cycle and host plants

Caterpillars feed on a range of legumes, including vetches (Vicia), crown vetch (Coronilla) and lucerne (Medicago), plus bird’s-foot trefoils (Lotus), brooms (Cytisus) and clovers (Trifolium)1; in Britain the caterpillars rely mostly on clover and lucerne. Females lay their eggs singly, spread across many species of the pea family; each egg is pale when first laid, turning deep orange and then purple before hatching, about ten days later. The caterpillar passes through six instars and the species overwinters as a half-grown caterpillar. In Britain, caterpillars that hatch in late summer enter that dormant stage roughly a month to five weeks after hatching and stay torpid for about four months, but the larva appears unable to survive a British winter. Before pupating the caterpillar spins a silk girdle to attach itself to the food plant, and the pupal stage lasts around two weeks. In a non-hibernating summer brood, the larval stage itself lasts about a month, and the species produces two to three generations a year depending on location and altitude2; in Britain, migrant breeding and fresh arrivals can stack up to three generations in a favourable year3.

Behaviour and flight period

In Britain, migrants are seen from May to September, with the earliest arrivals in May or June and the main wave in August and early September; British sightings are thought to originate from northern France or central Europe. The later sightings in that spread are a mix of locally bred offspring and further fresh arrivals from the continent. This fast-flying butterfly is probably overlooked given its similarity to the more common clouded yellow3.

Similar species

  • Clouded yellow (Colias croceus): its ground colour runs orange to golden yellow4 against the pale clouded yellow’s lemon tone, a tone distinctive even in flight, unlike any other species5. See its profile for the full description.
  • Berger’s clouded yellow (Colias alfacariensis): the two are next to impossible to separate as adults without rearing them from caterpillars3; away from the wing, Berger’s clouded yellow keeps to calcareous grassland2, also described as calcareous grassland and dry, lightly wooded ground6, while the pale clouded yellow also breeds in clover and lucerne fields off the chalk and limestone. See its profile for more.