Scarce tortoiseshell (Nymphalis xanthomelas), a species in the family Nymphalidae.
Photo: Didier Descouens · Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA
Contents
  1. Identification
  2. Range and habitat
  3. Life cycle and host plants
  4. Behaviour
  5. Similar species

The scarce tortoiseshell, Nymphalis xanthomelas — also known as the yellow-legged tortoiseshell — is a large2, orange butterfly of the family Nymphalidae, closely related to the large tortoiseshell4. Sources disagree on who first described it: one credits Denis & Schiffermüller, in 1775, as Papilio xanthomelas, another instead credits Esper, in 1781. It ranges from Eastern Europe to Japan, including the Himalayas from Kashmir to Mussoorie, and has turned up as far as south-east England3. In Eastern Europe it is a lowland species of damp woodland on flood plains and river banks1.

Identification

The butterfly has a wingspan of about 63–68 mm3, with an upperside that is rich orange-yellow, the forewing’s leading edge dusky black on the inner half and flecked with brown, two black spots in the cell, and a sinuous black band crossing both wings before the border, which itself is a dusky band flecked with golden brown. The underside is a duller ochreous brown, finely streaked with slender dark brown lines, with a row of dark blue crescents forming a band near the edge of both wings. Away from the wings, the antennae, head and thorax are a very dark brown, while the abdomen is fulvous, a tawny orange-brown. The sexes are similar, though the female carries an extra, incomplete row of yellow crescents bordering the black band on the upperside.

The caterpillar is distinctive in its own right: cylindrical and slightly hairy, with a dorsal row of short spines3 on the third to last segments and a pair of slender yellowish lines running down its back.

Range and habitat

In Eastern Europe the species keeps to damp, flood-plain woodland along wooded stream and river banks, including mixed, alluvial and deciduous forest1. A single record from much further west, recorded by Christine Foord at Shipbourne, Kent, in 19533, stood alone until the UK’s next sighting, in 20142, reflecting occasional long-distance wandering, not an established population.

That wandering showed up on a larger scale in 2014, when, from the middle to the end of July, more than 20 sightings were reported in several English counties, mainly along the east coast but reaching as far as Devon, Tyneside and the West Midlands. Around the same period, the species had also been spreading westwards towards Sweden2 on the continent. One of the 2014 influx then survived the winter and was seen flying again the following March, the first time the species was recorded overwintering successfully in Britain; further overwintered individuals turned up around the same time in Suffolk, Cambridgeshire and Sussex; the Cambridgeshire butterfly, seen at a nature reserve, had wings so worn that they showed it had emerged from hibernation rather than arrived fresh, though no UK-born adult of the species had yet been recorded5.

Life cycle and host plants

Caterpillars feed on willows, poplars, elms and nettle tree (Salix, Populus, Ulmus and Celtis australis respectively), and also on Pistacia integerrima3. Until nearly fully grown, the caterpillars live together in large communal nests spun in branches that hang over the water. That choice of nest site mirrors the adult’s own preference for flood-plain woodland. The species is single-brooded, producing one generation a year1.

Behaviour

The scarce tortoiseshell overwinters as an adult, hibernating in sheltered spots such as hollow trees or wood piles. With a single generation a year, the same adults that hibernate are the ones that must survive winter for the population to continue, as the 2014–15 British overwintering records illustrate. Choosing flood-plain woodland near water also fits the caterpillars’ habit of nesting communally in branches that hang over the water1 until nearly fully grown, so that the generation’s habitat needs run from wooded riverbank as a caterpillar to sheltered hollow as a hibernating adult.

Similar species

  • Large tortoiseshell (Nymphalis polychloros): bigger, with a 68–75 mm wingspan; its tarsi are dark-haired, against the scarce tortoiseshell’s light-coloured tarsal hairs4, and its leg colour and forewing markings are darker than the scarce tortoiseshell’s6.
  • Small tortoiseshell (Aglais urticae): much smaller, with a 4.5–6.2 cm wingspan7 against the scarce tortoiseshell’s 63–68 mm3.
  • Nymphalis vaualbum: another Nymphalis species, usually marked beneath by a V- or L-shaped mark on the hindwing that shows up more strongly in males than in females, though in some individuals it is reduced to a few scales or absent8 altogether.